Oh look. They met at a church. This totally disproves my theories. Oh wait, it does just the opposite.

From the article Marsh posted above:
Showvay and Schipper went on to tie the knot and settle into a life that Showvay remembers thinking was “too good to be true.” Not long after, Schipper came to his wife with a jarring confession: He'd had a sexual “encounter in a public bathroom with a man.”
I'm shocked, shocked I tell you.