That statement by the Gila County Sheriff’s Office spawned national headlines, with officials there saying they had been left “dumbfounded” to find that — after all these years — Plante was a 44-year-old woman living with her own family under a new name, having voluntarily left home.
The truth was, in fact, a bit more complicated but had already been well known by law enforcement back in the 1990s, one of the original investigators on the case now says.
A former Gila County sheriff’s deputy, Terry Hudgens, told NBC News that Plante, who went by Tina, was in a “custody battle” and wanted to live with her mom, not her father.
So the teen met up with her mother while heading to her stable to see her horse back in 1994 and the pair left Arizona on a flight, Hudgens said.
He said they may have even flown “out of the country.”
Plante was found to be safe at the time, Hudgens said, though the sheriff’s office maintains her case was never officially been resolved until recently.
"We're still in the process of looking into what happened and as new information develops we will be providing updates," the chief deputy, James Lahti, told NBC.
In an updated statement on Friday, April 3, Gila Sheriff J. Adam Shepherd said that Plante had been first reported missing by an uncle.
At the time, authorities traced a vehicle suspected to be involved in her disappearance to a nearby hotel and “deputies believed Christina may have been taken by her non-custodial parent, her mother.”
But “that information could not be verified at the time,” according to the new statement.