Shawn Munck (22) allegedly killed his 12 year old brother and asked for help on Myspace

[nestlequikie]

[quote author=Munck link=topic=12877.msg1393557#msg1393557 date=1253625787]
Why didn't the girlfriend contact police? Idk
Why didn't CPS notice the victim lying dead in bed? Idk
Did the grandmother contact her grandson while she was in the hospital? No.

and your right...i am. {Shawn is a weirdo}
[/quote]

So you are saying that you are Shawn??

Ya'll have internet in the jails there?

[Jonelle]

[quote author=Munck link=topic=12877.msg1393557#msg1393557 date=1253625787]
Why didn't the girlfriend contact police? Idk
Why didn't CPS notice the victim lying dead in bed? Idk
Did the grandmother contact her grandson while she was in the hospital? No.

and your right...i am. {Shawn is a weirdo}
[/quote]

Oooh I hope he stays. Have we ever had an actual prisoner become a member of MDS ?

                                                            &

I saw that the vampyr girl was writing here saying that she was not his gf. I wonder who this is ? Is it the same girl ? I somehow missed this thread back then. But the girl who's link I'm posting is on two of his most recent profiles and has also not logged in since June 08. Could this maybe be the internet GF ? She is 18 now and out of state. Would make sense as to why her name wouldn't have been released by the police, because she would have been underage ... Just a thought. 

http://www.myspace.com/caydenceann

[Onthedarkside]

[quote author=Munck link=topic=12877.msg1393555#msg1393555 date=1253625668]
Thanks. thats all i need to say. {i'm peters bro}
[/quote]



How is that?
Have you been to court yet?

[Jonelle]

[quote author=nestlequikie link=topic=12877.msg1393562#msg1393562 date=1253627403]
So you are saying that you are Shawn??

Ya'll have internet in the jails there?
[/quote]

Holy shit Nestle they convicted him of a lesser charge. He's not in jail, at least not until his sentencing. Scratch me wanting him to stay ! Check out the mug shot :)


http://www.pressconnects.com/article/20090831/NEWS01/908310380/1112


*** Shawn Munck left jail Monday a free man after a jury declined to convict him of felony manslaughter or assault in the 2008 death of his 12-year-old brother.

Instead, the jury of 10 men and two women convicted the 23-year-old of the lesser charge of criminally negligent homicide in Peter Munck's Feb. 12, 2008, death.

Broome County Judge Martin E. Smith released Munck from custody shortly after the jury announced its verdict less than three hours after deliberating his fate Monday afternoon.

Munck has already served 1 1/2 years in the Broome County Jail while awaiting his trial. The maximum sentence for his conviction is 1 to 4 years in prison. The Endwell man will be sentenced Oct. 30, the judge said.

[Munck]

[quote author=nestlequikie link=topic=12877.msg1393562#msg1393562 date=1253627403]
So you are saying that you are Shawn??

Ya'll have internet in the jails there?
[/quote]

Yes, i'm shawn Munck. and no.jail doesnt..i'm free. or dont you check the news?

[Munck]

[quote author=Jonelle link=topic=12877.msg1393573#msg1393573 date=1253628941]
Holy shit Nestle they convicted him of a lesser charge. He's not in jail, at least not until his sentencing. Scratch me wanting him to stay ! Check out the mug shot :)



[/quote]

I'll get time served....thats what Judge Martin E smith told me in court sept 1st.

[nestlequikie]

[quote author=Munck link=topic=12877.msg1393575#msg1393575 date=1253629329]
Yes, i'm shawn Munck. and no.jail doesnt..i'm free. or dont you check the news?
[/quote]

No, I didn't...

So you are free pending sentencing. 

[s]Do you know it you will get credit for time served?[/s]  Nevermind I think you just answered Jonelle.

So essentially you are done then.

Are you back living with your family now?

[Jonelle]

[quote author=Munck link=topic=12877.msg1393577#msg1393577 date=1253629500]
I'll get time served....thats what Judge Martin E smith told me in court sept 1st.
[/quote]

Yes I read that. It carries a 1-4 year sentence and you've already served 1 1/2.

[Munck]

[quote author=nestlequikie link=topic=12877.msg1393579#msg1393579 date=1253629699]


No, I didn't...

So you are free pending sentencing. 

[s]Do you know it you will get credit for time served?[/s]  Nevermind I think you just answered Jonelle.

So essentially you are done then.

Are you back living with your family now?
[/quote]

No i'm not living with my family at the present time...i live out in endicott....
Its messed up i know but it's just something i gotta live with.

and yep...i got probation for the rest of the 4 years...thats all.

[emmy_dreamy]

I have no problem with Shawn being here given that the report that was quoted states that although what he did was irresponsible, negligent maybe, there were preexisting issues that lead to the death of his brother.

he judge said Friday that medical testimony indicated Peter Munck had a previous tear in the abdominal artery where a second injury made him bleed to death.

Senior Assistant District Attorney Rita M. Basile alleged Shawn Munck stomped on his brother's abdomen and then failed to seek medical treatment for him. But no one was aware of the earlier injury and doctors said even slight pressure may have caused Peter's artery to tear again, said Patrick Kilker, Shawn Munck's defense attorney.

I can see this being a horrible accident.  Although it's never ok to assault anyone, it happens between siblings.  Shawn, you were 22 and old enough to control yourself but that being said, I don't think your intention was to kill Peter.  

Rip Peter

[Munck]

[quote author=emmy_dreamy link=topic=12877.msg1393583#msg1393583 date=1253629935]
I have no problem with Shawn being here given that the report that was quoted states that although what he did was irresponsible, negligent maybe, there were preexisting issues that lead to the death of his brother.

I can see this being a horrible accident.  Although it's never ok to assault anyone, it happens between siblings.  Shawn, you were 22 and old enough to control yourself but that being said, I don't think your intention was to kill Peter.  

Rip Peter
[/quote]

your right, it wasnt, but he didnt look hurt to me thats why i didnt get help when i should...and i know that now....and i'm a f****** retard because of it. i know this.

[Munck]

The reason i'm on this s*** is that i wanna set the record straight about my brother...

in court the witness Joe said my brother laughed before, during, and after the horseplay incident.

and due to prior {unknowable} injury, he bled to death.

[nestlequikie]

[quote author=Munck link=topic=12877.msg1393582#msg1393582 date=1253629861]
No i'm not living with my family at the present time...i live out in endicott....
Its messed up i know but it's just something i gotta live with.

and yep...i got probation for the rest of the 4 years...thats all.
[/quote]

That has to be hard for you (the not living with your family part).

I hope you can use what happened as a pivot point in your life.  You get that chance - Peter didn't. 

[quote author=Munck link=topic=12877.msg1393585#msg1393585 date=1253630068]
your right, it wasnt, but he didnt look hurt to me thats why i didnt get help when i should...and i know that now....and i'm a f****** retard because of it. i know this.
[/quote]

You aren't a retard - I'd like to believe that you simply used incredibly poor judgement in your horseplay with your brother.  I'd also like to believe you didn't report it because you were scared and/or in denial.

Try to live your life in honor of your brother...  I am sure if he could tell you so - he would rather your life not be wasted.

RIP Peter

Good luck with your future, Shawn.  If you decide to stay around beyond today, welcome to MDS.

[Jonelle]

[quote author=Munck link=topic=12877.msg1393585#msg1393585 date=1253630068]
your right, it wasnt, but he didnt look hurt to me thats why i didnt get help when i should...and i know that now....and i'm a f****** retard because of it. i know this.
[/quote]

But why did you wait 3 days ... surely you knew he was dead after awhile ? I'm assuming there are questions you most likely will not be answering until after your sentencing. Am I correct ?

[Munck]

[quote author=nestlequikie link=topic=12877.msg1393587#msg1393587 date=1253630376]
That has to be hard for you (the not living with your family part).

I hope you can use what happened as a pivot point in your life.  You get that chance - Peter didn't. 

You aren't a retard - I'd like to believe that you simply used incredibly poor judgement in your horseplay with your brother.   I'd also like to believe you didn't report it because you were scared and/or in denial.

Try to live your life in honor of your brother...  I am sure if he could tell you so - he would rather your life not be wasted.

RIP Peter

Good luck with your future, Shawn.  If you decide to stay around beyond today, welcome to MDS.
[/quote]

I live as my brother, not for my brother. {fyi}

and if you see my last post jonelle you'll see why.

[Jonelle]

[quote author=Munck link=topic=12877.msg1393590#msg1393590 date=1253630516]
I live as my brother, not for my brother. {fyi}

and if you see my last post jonelle you'll see why.
[/quote]

That is what I responded to. I am not giving you a hard time. I'm curious - I'd like to think there is a distinctive difference between someone lying recently deceased than someone with rigor, skin discoloration and low body temp. I'm serious. You didn't touch him at all ?

[Munck]

[quote author=Jonelle link=topic=12877.msg1393596#msg1393596 date=1253630709]
That is what I responded to. I am not giving you a hard time. I'm curious - I'd like to think there is a distinctive difference between someone lying recently deceased than someone with rigor, skin discoloration and low body temp. I'm serious. You didn't touch him at all ?
[/quote]

no, i looked in from the doorway, into a dark room...{the way he liked it while watching tv-which was on- and while playing video games}

[ICDEDPPL]

[quote author=nestlequikie link=topic=12877.msg1393587#msg1393587 date=1253630376]
I hope you can use what happened as a pivot point in your life.[/quote]I hope so as well.

[Munck]

and fyi, my brother wouldnt take anything seriously, so i cant. so dont worry....-to jonelle

and i will...i live as if i was my brother....

[tanya2012]

[quote author=Munck link=topic=12877.msg1393599#msg1393599 date=1253630780]
no, i looked in from the doorway, into a dark room...{the way he liked it while watching tv-which was on- and while playing video games}
[/quote]

So when you talked to your girlfriend was it the day it happened or after the three days? In the conversation it said you knew he was dead.

[Jonelle]

[quote author=Munck link=topic=12877.msg1393599#msg1393599 date=1253630780]
no, i looked in from the doorway, into a dark room...{the way he liked it while watching tv-which was on- and while playing video games}
[/quote]


Clearly a jury believed you weren't as guilty as originally thought. You have to understand that since you bumped this thread we are going to be inquisitive. So the part where your friend said you supposedly went in to check on him was exaggerated ?  Was the girl from PA, in your profile the online gf ? As you can see we are very curious as to who she was as a person.

[Munck]

[quote author=tanya2012 link=topic=12877.msg1393606#msg1393606 date=1253630976]
So when you talked to your girlfriend was it the day it happened or after the three days? In the conversation it said you knew he was dead.
[/quote]

That was the day i found out and freaked out.

[quote author=Jonelle link=topic=12877.msg1393608#msg1393608 date=1253631037]

Clearly a jury believed you weren't as guilty as originally thought. You have to understand that since you bumped this thread we are going to be inquisitive. So the part where your friend said you supposedly went in to check on him was exaggerated ?  Was the girl from PA, in your profile the online gf ? As you can see we are very curious as to who she was as a person.
[/quote]

all me friend knew was that i went to my brothers room, not that i went to him.
yes she was.
i couldnt tell u who she was. i still dont know.

{& i understand the inquisitiveness, i would be. thats y i'm here.

[Jonelle]

[quote author=Munck link=topic=12877.msg1393609#msg1393609 date=1253631233]
all me friend knew was that i went to my brothers room, not that i went to him.
yes she was.
i couldnt tell u who she was. i still dont know.

{& i understand the inquisitiveness, i would be. thats y i'm here.
[/quote]

That is what I suspected, the thing that baffles me is why a 17 yr old girl would not contact police. Odd. This is my last question for ... The articles state that you were not arrested until the either IM or email was discovered. What was so damning in that particular conversation that lead them to believe that you knew you had killed him and were looking to cover it up. (other than the obvious)

[Munck]

[quote author=Jonelle link=topic=12877.msg1393614#msg1393614 date=1253631631]
That is what I suspected, the thing that baffles me is why a 17 yr old girl would not contact police. Odd. This is my last question for ... The articles state that you were not arrested until the either IM or email was discovered. What was so damning in that particular conversation that lead them to believe that you knew you had killed him and were looking to cover it up. (other than the obvious)
[/quote]

well it stated that i horseplayed with him and "knew" i killed him that way. {which is the only explanation i could make at the time....}

[Munck]

i'm gonna head out and play world or warcraft...so if you want...email me more questions at jwchimera@mail.com of snail mail at *******************************