I live in Columbus Ohio and surprisingly at least to me, it's not a huge news story like I expected it to be. Most of what I know is what I've read online. Anyways- I would think if the two year old can say "My mommy's in the rug" "My mommy broke the table" and various other statements, I would think had his father done this to Jessie, the two year old would be quick to point that out. He had contact with his father often, he knew his dad. If the father does has something to do with it, being a cop I know he would probably be smart enough to hire someone to do his dirty work.
It would make sense to me if the father did have something to do with it because maybe he wanted the baby, but not Jessie. So he had someone take her out of the home, deliver the baby so he could keep his child then do whatever with Jessie. I don't think it would be hard to figure out where a nurse lives in Wooster.
Okay, hope this made sense, it's late.